Anecdotes involving Rav and Shemuel

Ruling like Rav against Shemuel, in all but three cases: Menachot 41b

Set of joint-statements with Rav on blood-letting: Shabbat 129a-b

Rav was called to the Torah for the first reading, which normally goes to a Kohen, even if Shemuel was present: Megillah 22a

Rav always had Shemuel enter before him, to show respect to Shemuel: Megillah 22a

Shemuel challenging Rav's students on something that Rav had taught them: Kiddushin 25b

Shemuel called Rav by his real name, "Abba": Eruvin 78a, 94a; Pesachim 119b; Taanit 4b

Shemuel having Rav teach him a Law 40 times: Ketuvot 22b

Shemuel sent Karna to test Rav: Shabbat 108a

Shemuel fed Rav food to loosen his stuck bowels: Shabbat 108a

Rav cursed him for causing him pain, that he shouldn't have sons: Shabbat 108a

Shemuel and Rav lived by a yard around which all of the residents had merged, to permit transport in the yard on Shabbat. The wall separating their yard from another yard collapsed on Shabbat. Shemuel held there was no need to fix it, but he did so for the sake of privacy. Rav held one couldn't carry the item needed to fix the wall, and he turned his back on the proceedings, but he didn't protest as it was Shemuel's place: Eruvin 94a

Shemuel tore 13 garments when Rav's death was mentioned, saying, "The man I was afraid of is gone.": Moed Katan 24a

Rav cited a law, and said he did not know the reason; "it is a Gemara [tradition]." Shemuel responded, "Abba does not know the reason? This is the reason...": Eruvin 78a

Rav Chiyya bar Yosef asked Shemuel regarding a certain debate, "Does the law follow you, or does it follow Rav?" Shemuel responded that the law follows Rav: Eruvin 90b

Shemuel rejects a Talmud-text-changing answer of Rav: Eruvin 94b

Shemuel's approach was followed by people in Neherdaa and its suburbs; Rav's approach was followed by people in Bavel and its suburbs: Ketuvot 54a

Rabbi Elazar quoted a lesson of Rav to Shemuel; Shemuel disapproved forcefully, declaring, "Feed Elazar barley [as in: animal fodder]"! When Rabbi Zeira made aliyah to Israel he heard Rabbi Binyamin bar Yefet quote the lesson in the name of Rabbi Yochanan, and he quoted Shemuel's criticism: Ketuvot 77a

: Ketuvot 77a


Back to Home
Search by Category
Search by Google



WWW Webshas


Alphabetical Index
About WebShas